TWC Thoughts, Week 2

Brief Overview/Summary

This lesson is split into two, the first of which is on Technology, Society and Global Dominance. We started off by identifying the dominant force in different dimensions (Eg.US culture is the most dominant throughout the world). Following that, we were introduced to the model of Rising Star, Falling Star, Dominant Player, as well as the characteristics of each model. We learnt that this can be applied to countries, companies, individuals, etc. From the readings, we can also see a fresh perspective on colonialism which I will elaborate on later.

Next, we moved on to Technology and Human Development where we touched on different kinds of development, especially sustainable development which will be economic development without negative environmental consequences. Thereafter, we discussed human development where one way to measure it will be through the Human Development Index(HDI) which is largely based on three broad areas namely: Health, Education and Income. There is also the United Nations Millennium Development Goals 2015 that aims to get worldwide cooperation to help the poor countries to attain a certain living standard.

Interesting Observations and Ideas

Technology, Society and Global Dominance

The reading on colonialism basically took most of us by surprise as we are so used to the idea that colonial powers brought progress to their colonies(Eg. The British helped to construct roads for Singapore). This cannot be further from the truth.  In fact, evidence has shown that colonial powers exploited their colonies by destroying their key industries and made the natives slaves. They also plundered their colonies for resources and produce. This is shown by China and India’s fall in the economic charts from 1500AD to 2000AD. Through this, we realized the devastating and crippling effect that European colonial powers brought onto their colonies.

My next observation will be from what Prof mentioned in class about Kodak and Fujiflim. Initially, Kodak was the dominant player in the photo(flim) industry, and it even came up with the digital camera first. However, it took a falling star approach by keeping the ideas of a digital camera within itself and not sharing it with others. Soon, its competitors such as Fujiflim eventually developed their expertise in digital photography and overtook them in the industry. Till today Kodak is a pale shadow of its former self. This shows that we must take a rising star approach by embracing change, constantly reinventing ourselves(by staying hungry) so that we will become the dominant power in the respective domains(countries/companies/individual).

In addition, I would like to make a bold prediction with regards to the rivalry between Apple and Samsung. In the last couple of years, Apple's innovation stagnated while Samsung reinvented itself and caught up. Although Apple currently still has a larger market share than Samsung and is still THE dominant player, I cannot help but think that they are taking a falling star approach by suing Samsung over many copyright infringements so that they can maintain the status quo. Samsung on the other hand is fast progressing by coming up with many new technologies such as the 'eye movement to read' and flexible screen technology. Compared to Apple's approach of sticking to a tried and tested iphone formula with minimal improvements, I feel that Samsung is the rising star which will dominate for years to come.

Technology and Human Development

Lastly will be my observation with regards to the HDI which is used to measure human development. I agree with many of my peers’ response(on their blogs) that the HDI is a flawed way to measure human development. This is due to the fact that the HDI does not measure the intangible things such as happiness and stress levels. Hence I find it rather interesting that the concept of Gross National Happiness(GNH) has become more commonly used in recent years. Hopefully, this will signal to the governing parties that economic development should not be the sole focus and considerations should be made for their citizen’s happiness and well-being.

Key Take Away Points

One should always have a rising star mentality and be hungry for more knowledge so that we can be at the forefront of changes and not get caught flatfooted when change takes place.

As countries all around the world have got to a certain stage in development, sustainable development will become the next big thing. This is because environmental/governmental organizations around the world are starting to come together to prohibit unsustainable development that causes irreversible environmental damage to the Earth. Hence, companies/economies should focus their efforts on sustainable development as I feel that whoever can embrace this change best will be the leading light in development.

Issues for Further Discussion

In light of our realizations about colonialism, would Singapore be in a better position now if we are not a British colony before?

Personal Views on Presentations

I would like to weigh in my views on the presentation on Childhood Education and Eugenics.

Wen Bin - Childhood Education

I feel that the role of teachers can never be adequately replaced by technology. Technology can have all the content and resources needed for our development but it will always lack the human touch. Things like morals, ethics and behaviors can never be taught through technology. In addition, if a child is educated solely through technology, he/she will be lacking in EQ to deal with real situations. Thus, the individual will be severely handicapped if there are no teachers to guide him/her along in the educational journey. 

Sylvester – Eugenics(shared on Facebook)

I feel that the problem with eugenics is human's greed. Sure Eugenics may have started off with good intentions, such as preventing diseases and disabilities. And I agree with these objectives wholeheartedly. But human's greed will make the next step seem inevitable and soon it will be alright to use eugenics as a method to counter obesity. Naturally, next in line will be genes that modify looks, increase intelligence, and sex selection(which will undoubtedly be used in China given the large number of female fetuses being aborted). We might say that this will not happen as we can draw up ethical guidelines to guide our progress in this field. However, our greedy nature will lead us down this slippery slope of no return and that is the danger in embracing eugenics. 

Unfortunately, or fortunately in the case of eugenics, our progress in human development is still far from satisfactory. Like what Prof has mentioned, children across the world are still dying of preventable causes like hunger and having no access to drinking water. Thus I feel that until these problems are solved, we have no right to use eugenics to improve our own developed societies while other third world countries languish behind and suffer. Then, they might never be able to get out of their abyss.

Personal Ratings for Session 

I found the lesson and presentations to be very engaging and would give it a 8/10. However it would be even better if we had enough time to discuss about the issues brought up in the presentations.